Go back

Randy Zook in the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette: When Justice Becomes A Jackpot

Arkansas Supreme Court

(In a Nov. 15 Arkansas Democrat-Gazette column, Arkansas State Chamber of Commerce/Associated Industries of Arkansas President and CEO Randy Zook explained what a recent Arkansas Supreme Court decision in Old Dominion Freight Line v. McMillion signals to businesses considering investing in Arkansas, and what lawmakers, the courts and the business community should do next. Read the full column here and below.)

When Justice Becomes A Jackpot

by Randy Zook

Over the past decade, the Arkansas economy has been thriving. In July, an annual report by CNBC titled “America’s Top States for Business” identified Arkansas as the country’s most improved state, having jumped 13 spots to No. 28.

In April, the American Legislative Exchange Council ranked Arkansas sixth for economic outlook in its “Rich States, Poor States” index. Countless other sources and data highlight this recent success. Suffice it to say, things have been going well.

But that success took a body blow Nov. 5, when four members of the Arkansas Supreme Court handed down the majority opinion in Old Dominion Freight Line Inc. and Aaron Marvell Foster v. Frank McMillion, et al.

The case involves the wreck of a tractor-trailer carrying a hazardous chemical. Responders to the wreck were exposed to the chemical and sued Old Dominion for failing to notify them of its presence. The six claimants alleged various ongoing health issues, primarily associated with breathing, due to the exposure.

The total amount of medical bills introduced into evidence for the six claimants was less than $15,200, and there was no evidence submitted that any of them would incur future medical expenses or lose wages because of the exposure. So it came as a surprise when the jury awarded them a stunning $75 million for pain and suffering, an amount almost 5,000 times more than the medical bills.

Going back to old English common law, courts have had the authority to reduce an excessive jury verdict if it isn’t supported by the evidence, shocks the conscience, or demonstrates passion or prejudice. So the defendants appealed the verdict to the Arkansas Court of Appeals with a request to do just that, and a six-member panel of that court unanimously found the verdict to be excessive. The plaintiffs then appealed that decision to the Arkansas Supreme Court, which, by a 4-3 margin, upheld the $75 million verdict as appropriate.

To put that in context, 13 appellate judges passed upon the propriety of this verdict, and nine of them agreed that it was excessive and should be reduced. Four of them, on the other hand, were able to reinstate the verdict.

State Supreme Court Justice Cody Hiland, in his dissent, said it best: “The law does not permit juries to convert transitory or moderate injuries into generational wealth, but that is what this court just allowed. The appellees had less than $15,200 in total medical expenses, yet they walked away with $75 million. That signals a sea change in our jurisprudence, and it transforms our civil justice system into something far more arbitrary–an institutionalized lottery, dispensing windfalls untethered from actual damages and the rule of law.”

The economic development implications are staggering. Anyone considering Arkansas for an investment must grapple with this new legal reality. They must decide whether they want to invest in a state whose high court has declined to exercise a long-standing legal authority and will allow any and all verdicts to stand. Even if a business avoids such a tragic verdict, the cost of planning for its possibility will be high.

In a time where investment firms are financing claims to monetize lawsuits for profit and outright financing the operations of personal injury law firms, our Supreme Court has hung out the “Welcome to Arkansas” sign for those interests. Because of these practices, our civil justice system has strayed dramatically from the basic purpose of a tort claim–making a plaintiff whole–and turned it into a commodity where the motivation is to squeeze every dime possible out of a defendant regardless of the true nature of the harm suffered.

As a side note, these lawsuit and law firm funding mechanisms require scrutiny here in Arkansas. It’s my hope that the Legislature will pass a law regulating lawsuit financing, and I urge our Supreme Court to assess whether these law firm funding arrangements–known as a managed service organization–require changes to the court’s rules. The supreme courts of South Carolina and Tennessee are considering that now.

Under our civil justice system, a person injured through the fault of another should be able to recover. That person should be made whole or put back in the same position as before the accident. In this case, however, the plaintiffs were made rich.

If the court is going to abandon its duty to reduce clearly excessive verdicts, we must renew discussions around adopting damage caps. Perhaps more important, the business community must be more engaged in judicial elections to ensure the people who wear the robes will follow the law.

Randy Zook is president and CEO of the Arkansas State Chamber of Commerce/Associated Industries of Arkansas.